Consciousness Studies Online
http://www.MetanoiaMind.com
Consciousness Studies Online

Green Tea & Consciousness: Can you help?

Hi Everyone,
                         I'd like to ask for your assistance with a scholarship contest I recently entered, the TEA USA Calm-a-Sutra Video Scholarship. I created and entered a 2-minute video, which you can check out here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MMFWGW7fQbc. It literally takes only 2 minutes to watch, and you could help me out by giving it a quick glimpse. 10% of the judges' scores will be based on how many hits my video receives. I hope you'll find it interesting and enlightening.

Oh, and by the way, the scholarship is for $20,000, which I would hope to use when I transfer to Naropa University next year. And in case you'd like to enter a video for yourself, you can find the scholarship info here: http://www.teausa.org/calmasutra/. The deadline is 8/6/08 at midnight, so there is still time.

Thanks for your support!

Best wishes,
Eric Thompson

Activating the Brain's "Peace Circuits"

"Is it really possible to activate inherent "peace circuits" within the brain?"

“Can peace be literally hardwired into the brain through mental training?”

I'll discuss two research studies that strongly infer that, yes, it is indeed possible to activate "peace circuits" within the brain and stablize them through cocnsistent mental practice.

In their scholarly paper, "Making a life worth living: Neural correlates of Wellbeing," Heather Urry and colleagues discuss their research findings on the particular neural firing patterns that mediate a profound sense of wellbeing, which they define as "eudaimonic wellbeing." According to neuroscientist Daniel J. Siegel, eudaimonic wellbeing “is more about a sense of equanimity than about the sensory pleasure focus of hedonia [i.e., pleasure through external stimulation]. A eudaimonic form of well-being embraces the psychological qualities of autonomy, mastery of the environment, positive relationships, personal growth, self-acceptance, and meaning and purpose in life." The higher levels of such wellbeing are intimately associated with profound peace and joy, and are less dependent upon outer surroundings and more dependent upon an individual's perceptions, interpretations, and inner way of being in the world.

The specific neural correlates of eudaimonic wellbeing — greater activity in the left prefrontal lobe, also define the basic neural shift that takes place with consistent practice of most forms of meditation. Numerous studies have highlighted meditation’s tendency to catalyze this left prefrontal shift, activating the brain sites most highly correlated with higher levels of meaning, purpose, peace, and compassion.

A scholarly paper by Antoine Lutz and company, "Long-term meditators self-induce high-amplitude gamma synchrony during mental practice," demonstrates this observation well.

Eight Tibetan Buddhists with a range of 15 – 40 years of prior training were examined during meditation. A control group of 10 student volunteers also participated. The two groups practiced Metta meditation, a “non-referential state of loving kindness and compassion.” Feelings of loving kindness and compassion are allowed to permeate one’s mental field.

Several interesting observations became apparent:

  • There was more gamma band activity during relaxed states among Buddhist practitioners.
  • 5 to 15 seconds after the meditation began, all meditators exhibited extraordinarily high degrees of 
     synchronized gamma activity. 
  • The more hours each practitioner had practiced during prior years, the higher was their absolute gamma  
     activity.
  • Long-distance synchronizations were evident between the frontal
     and parietal leads. Long-term practitioners exhibited the highest degree of these synchronization effects.
  • Two areas of the brain that were significantly active during meditation were the caudate and putamen: the 
     formation of habits at successively higher-order behavioral and cognitive levels.
  • Significant gamma band activity increased in the left middle frontal gyrus, which is correlated with positive 
     emotions such as happiness, enthusiasm, and joy, as well as feelings of high energy and alertness.
  • One Buddhist practitioner’s gamma activity, in particular, was the highest ever recorded in history.

First, it's important to understand that gamma activity, which is between 30 Hz and 80 Hz (or cycles per second), is associated with higher than average levels of sensory unification, the kind associated with intense "aha" moments. In fact, Dr. Richard Davidson, one of the principle investigators, theorizes that these monks live in a perpetual "aha" moment, continuously experiencing life in richer, more meaningful, multi-faceted ways.

Secondly, much of this increased activity was taking place in the left prefrontal lobe, which indicates that the specific brain sites correlated with higher levels of wellbeing were being systematically activated and developed through willed mental training. In effect, these results strongly infer that our basic emotional disposition, contrary to popular belief, can in fact be transformed in time to reflect greater peace, poise, and equanimity. Another way to express this idea is, “Temporal states become permanent traits.” In other words, these temporary higher states of consciousness, when evoked consistently on a daily basis, are eventually integrated into the brain’s neural firing patterns as permanent traits.

NeuroNirvana: A Brain Scientist's Experience of Consciousness

"Oh my gosh, I'm having a stroke! I'm having a stroke! And in the next instant, the thought flashed through my mind, this is so cool!"

These were the thoughts of brain scientist (neuroanatomist) Dr. Jill Bolte Taylor as she was suffering a stroke in her left hemisphere. Remarkably, not only did she survive the experience, she also brought back a provocative story with profound implications. In this featured TED (Technology, Entertainment, Design) talk, Dr. Taylor discusses her view of the left and right brain hemispheres, as well as her first-person experience of the stroke and the surreal, nirvana-like insights she received while her left hemisphere was, for all practical purposes, "offline." In her presentation, she theorizes that, if we exercise our brain's "peace circuits" by conscious choice, we can eventually embody peace and radiate it outward into the world.

The video is about 19 minutes in length. The entire talk is intriguing, but the last 10 minutes are nothing less than amazing:
http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/view/id/229.

Dr. Taylor also appeared on a recent, short webcast with Oprah, wherein she expresses her belief that the neural correlates of profound inner peace are located deep within the core of the right hemisphere. You can view that video here:
http://www.oprah.com/spiritself/oss/guest/oss_guest_jboltetaylor.jhtml.

She has also written a provocative and highly recommended book, MY STROKE OF INSIGHT: A BRAIN SCIENTIST'S PERSONAL JOURNEY.

Questions:

Is it really possible to activate inherent "peace circuits" within the brain?

If so, how?

Can we cultivate peacefulness in a manner that actually hardwires peacefulness within the brain?

Is there really any scientific evidence for such an idea?

Is our society biased toward left-brained ways of being?

How do we, in Dr. Taylor's words, effectively "step to the right of our left brains"?

Are there specific methods for doing so?

Is there any research supporting the idea that humanity's deeper spiritual and altruistic capacities are mediated by the right brain?

What do YOU think?

Dan Rather Reports: Mind Science



The following is a link to a Dan Rather Reports special on neuroplasticity and the power of mental training to dramatically change the brain. It features the research done on the Tibetan Buddhist monks conducted by Antoine Lutz, Richard J. Davidson and colleagues. It also features an interview with the Dalai Lama: http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-4846933362481486227&hl=en

I believe an important factor here is that by simply being exposed to this research, there is the prospect of opening ourselves to possibilities not previously considered. A study conducted by Carol Dweck at Stanford University illustrates thise idea very well. She found that children who had been exposed to the implications of neuroplasticity, thereby coming to believe that intelligence was able to be developed, were more likely to excel academically. You can read more about that here:
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=7406521.

BRAINWAVE: an "only in New York" cultural festival

                                      

BRAINWAVE asks how art, music, and meditation affect the brain and offers countless answers in more than a hundred public events, ranging from an exhibition of contemporary art and a cinema series to cutting-edge concerts, performances, talks, and panels.

This "only in New York" cultural festival is organized by six New York institutions: Rubin Museum of Art, Exit Art, Science & the Arts at The Graduate Center of the City University of New York, The Philoctetes Center at the New York Psychoanalytic Institute, and the School of Visual Arts, in association with the Public Programs/American Museum of Natural History.


A Sampling of the Events:

RMA Friday, March 28, 7 p.m.

The Interfaith Experience: Spirituality, Science, and Consciousness: Exploring the Deepest Meeting Place

The second of the two-part presentation will explore current frontier studies in consciousness, science, and spirituality. With Dr. Kurt Johnson and Loch Kelley. FREE


RMA, Wednesday, March 5, 1 p.m.
Carl Jung and the Journey to Self-Discovery

Discussion Moderator: Armin Wanner, S.T.L., earned his degree from the Institute Catholique de Paris and is a practicing Jungian analyst in New York. He is a graduate of the C.G. Jung Institute in Zurich.

$10 / Free to RMA Members


 

RMA Saturday, February 9, 4 p.m.

The Tibetan Book of the Dead

What happens in our brains as we die'?"from the Tibetan Buddhist perspective. With Dr. Ramon Prats. $15


 

RMA Monday, April 7, 7 p.m.

The Satyagraha Synapse

Are we genetically predisposed to violence? Or are there other emotional forces at work that we are only now coming to understand? Mark Kurlansky, bestselling author of Cod and Salt and now of Nonviolence: Twenty-five Lessons From the History of a Dangerous Idea, exchanges ideas with neurologist Michael Meaney on the psychology of nonviolence to mark the new production of Philip Glass's opera Satyagraha at the Metropolitan Opera. Presented as part of The Satyagraha Forum $18

Aurobindo's Model of Consciousness: A Comparative Graphic View

Below is a graphic presentation based on Aurobindo's horizontal and vertical stage models of human consciousness, as compared with those espoused by Jean Piaget, Spiral Dynamics. Plotinus, and Vedanta (the koshas). The only parts of Aurobindo's vertical system not represented in this graphic are the Subconscient and the Inconscient. I also took the liberty of adding the higher cognitive levels of Commons and Richards to Piaget's cognitive stage model. For a clearer, more detailed view, press Cntrl and + to enlarge the screen.

Holarchical Bodies of the Upper Right Quadrant

The following is a graphic presentation I created, based upon Ken Wilber's Toward a Comprehensive Theory of Subtle Energies. The dotted arrows represent the substrate consciousness underlying all witnessed phenomena. For a closer, more detailed view, press Cntrl and + to enlarge the picture.

AQAL: A Graphic Presentation

This is a short (3.5 min) graphic presentation of the AQAL model ("All Quadrants, All Levels, All Lines, All States, All Types," sans "Types"), based on Ken Wilber's Integral Framework. The accompanying soundtrack includes brainwave entrainment designed to encourage relaxation, and incorporates a carrier frequency designed to enhance physical invigoration. (It is generally accepted that it takes the brain at least 6 minutes to entrain to an audio stimulus properly.) Natural holarchies of subtle energies (UR) and their corresponding states of consciousness (UL) are also graphically represented.


AQAL: A Graphic Presentation

Brainwave Frequencies and Correlated States of Consciousness

 
 
 Brainwave Frequencies Correlated States of Consciousness
Epsilon/sub-Delta: ¼ cycle per sec/1 frequency per 10 sec/1 frequency per minute - .4 Hz  Very rare, exceptional, ecstatic states of consciousness; deep spiritual insight; high level of inspiration; theorized to be the state Yogi's go into when no heart beat, respiration or pulse are noticeable.
Delta:  .5 Hz – 3.5 Hz  Deep dreamless sleep; formless/expansive awareness; very deep meditation; healing and recuperation; deep relaxation; empathy; experience of transcending time and space.
Theta: 4 Hz – 7.5 Hz  Hypnogogic state; dreaming sleep; creative inspiration; insight/problem solving; vivid visualization; meditation; OBE’s, shamanic journeying; learning and memory.
Alpha: 8 Hz – 11.5 Hz Accelerated learning; relaxed alertness; Zen meditation; open focus; nonlinear mental activity; the beginning of drowsiness and falling
asleep; can stimulate the release serotonin (vital in the regulation of mood and sleep). 
Beta: 12 Hz – 38 Hz Sensorimotor awareness; physical impulses; wide awake, alert, focused; analyzes and assimilates new information rapidly, complex mental processing, peak physical and mental performance, cannot be sustained indefinitely otherwise exhaustion, anxiety, and tension result.  Short bursts of beta have been used for improving cognitive intelligence, as well as euphoric states of short duration.
 Gamma: 38 Hz – 90 Hz

 Higher levels of brain organization; possesses a binding action noticeably absent in schizophrenic patients; above average integration of sensory information; hypnotic states; enhanced self awareness and insight; deep meditation; a sense of connection with the surrounding world; deepened compassion and loving kindness; clarity of mind. These brain waves are suppressed totally by anesthetic, which means they deeply influence waking consciousness and perception. Found in all parts of the brain, and are most prominent in highly developed practitioners of Tibetan Buddhist compassion meditation (metta) practice. 

Hyper Gamma: 100+ Hz

 

Lambda: 200+ Hz

Very rare; ecstatic states of consciousness; exceptional understanding and integration of sensory information; associated with the overcoming of barriers to personal development; tremendous focus/self awareness; deep feelings of love and joy. It has been theorized that Tibetan monks that walk barely clothed for days through the snow have exhibited high levels of these. They are difficult to measure and little is known about them. They are believed to be carried on the very slow moving Epsilon Waves (<0.5Hz).  

Yoga Nidra: a treatment for excessive self-referencing?



Recent research (led by brain researcher Troels Kjær of the Kennedy Institute, Copenhagen, Denmark) on the practice of Yoga Nidra showed significant increases in globally coherent Theta rhythms during the meditation period. With the added observation that decreases in Alpha were insignificant, this evoked state was easily distinguished from common sleep states. All participants described the evoked level of concentration and relaxation as being effortless, spontaneous, and self-arising—nothing more than the result of employing a simple method of releasing all obstacles to such effortless being.

>>

"It proves," stated the researchers, "that the 1.5 kg [brain mass] with the unknown content can control its own activity in an astonishingly precise manner. From a holistic point of view, it indicates that the soul and body act in unity.">>

> >

The occipital and parietal lobes were principally activated during the practice of Yoga Nidra, implying that (because of their connections to the limbic system) this practice opens access to emotions and particularly vivid visualization practice. And because the parietal lobe's correlation with tactile (body) and directional (spatial) imaging, an inference can be made about Yoga Nidra's capacity to enhance the meditator's egocentric spatial representation system; namely, that significant improvements in an individual's three-dimensional body representation and coordination are possible benefits of daily practice of Yoga Nidra.>>

> >

Interestingly, the junction at which the parietal, occipital, and temporal lobes meet has been associated with excessive self-referencing with the emergence of an infarct in that area. In the words of James H. Austin, people suffering from such an infarct (i.e., the death of tissue due to decreased blood flow) "seemed to have lost the normal frame of reference that we use to define, and cross over, a particular conceptual boundary, the boundary that separates our own construct of self from that of another living person." This being the case, it may be possible that Yoga Nidra practice enhances and cultivates the ability to integrate one's concept of "other" into the concept of "self," thus more profoundly harmonizing them.

 

>SOURCES

Austin, James H. Zen-Brain Reflections. Cambirdge, MA: MIT, 2006.

Lou, H C, et al. "A 15O-H2O PET study of meditation and the resting state of normal consciousness." Human Brain Mapping 7.2 (1999): 98-105.

>